What is Enhanced Turquoise?

Enhanced turquoise has been changed: dyed to add color, hardened by a process such as the Zachery treatment, or both. That is how we use the word at T.Skies. Not every seller uses it that way, and some books use "enhanced" for any treatment at all. So when the word matters to you, ask what was actually done to the stone.

The terms, in plain words

  • Natural: as it comes out of the earth. Nothing added except the water or mineral oil used while cutting.
  • Treated: anything else that's added (oil, wax, resin or any other additive, cooked or soaked in). Aligned with the IACB. Treated stone is one of:
    • Stabilized: clear resin locks in and protects the stone's own color and integrity.
    • Enhanced: the stone is changed: dyed (color added), hardened (e.g. the Zachery silica process), or both.
    • Stabilized Enhanced: stabilized and also dyed or hardened.
  • A stone can carry more than one label; we list every one that applies.

Upcycled & manufactured. Material made from turquoise, or from turquoise and other stone, rather than cut from a single stone: composite, chip inlay, reconstituted, block. None of it is natural turquoise. For stone bound with "any amount of filler or binder," the FTC says a name like "composite [gemstone name]" must disclose clearly that the product "[d]oes not have the same characteristics as the named stone" and "requires special care."[11] The whole vocabulary is in What Do These Confusing Turquoise Terms Mean?.

Why turquoise gets treated at all

Most turquoise comes out of the ground too soft to use as it is. The Indian Arts and Crafts Board's brochure puts it plainly: "approximately 85% of the turquoise is too soft to cut or polish. It can, however, be processed to enhance the color and increase the hardness of the stone."[10]

Stabilizing answers the softness. Clear resin fills the pores so the stone holds together, and the color you see is the stone's own. Enhancing goes one step further and changes the stone itself.

Dyed

Dye is the simplest enhancement: color added to a stone that didn't have enough of its own. It is also the least stable. Lowry warns that when a color dye is added to the stabilizing process, "the color is susceptible to breaking down over time due to direct sunlight or changing temperatures."[3] A dyed stone is enhanced, and a stabilized stone with dye in the resin is stabilized enhanced.

kingman turquoise dyed green

Kingman turquoise dyed green. A dyed stone is enhanced in our terms, whatever else has been done to it.

Hardened: the Zachery process

The best-known hardening process carries its inventor's name. The Lowrys tell the story: James E. Zachery grew up in a turquoise lapidary family, began experimenting with turquoise in the 1950s, and developed a patented process for medium-grade turquoise, not chalk, that can treat either cut cabochons or rough.[3] Citing a study titled "The Identification of Zachery-Treated Turquoise," the Lowrys report that Zachery recommended the phrase "micro-crystalline structurally enhanced by the Zachery process" for material treated this way.[3]

That study, by Fritsch and others (1999), is listed under Resources below. Some of the interviews quoted further down spell the name "Zachary"; we follow the Lowrys and the 1999 study.

Under our terms, Zachery-treated turquoise is enhanced (hardened).

The IACB draws its lines differently. Its "enhanced" is narrower than ours: "a patented process to darken the color of low or medium grade turquoise to imitate a higher grade color."[10] It lists Dyed and Oiled or waxed as separate entries, apart from Enhanced: oiled or waxed is turquoise "soaked or cooked in oil or wax to darken the color," and dyed is where "a pigment is added to deepen the stone's color or create a 'matrix' design within a treated stone."[10] Our label puts both under enhanced, because in each case something was added to change the stone's color.

Field Notes by Mateo James: how we use these words. At T.Skies we sort turquoise into three groups. Natural turquoise is as it comes out of the earth, with nothing added except the water or mineral oil used while cutting. Treated turquoise has something added, and we label it stabilized (clear resin that locks in the stone's own color and integrity), enhanced (dyed, hardened, or both), or stabilized enhanced. Upcycled and manufactured material (composite, chip inlay, reconstituted, block) is made from turquoise pieces or powder bound together, and it is its own category. The IACB's definitions, quoted above, say stabilizing also darkens the color, and keep 'enhanced' for one patented color process; our labels draw the line at whether dye or a hardening process changed the stone. Whatever the label, a treated stone should be disclosed as treated: the FTC Jewelry Guides (16 CFR §23.24) require it whenever a treatment isn't permanent, needs special care, or significantly affects the stone's value.[11]

Oiled or waxed

Oil and wax are the oldest treatments of all; the From the Library notes below go back to butter and mutton fat. Under our terms, a stone cooked or soaked in oil or wax to darken it is enhanced, because its color was changed. The Lowrys explain why that matters to a buyer: oil- and wax-processed stones "are susceptible to a slow loss or change of color," and white spots or lighter colors can appear as the oils or waxes slowly break down.[3]

Telling, and asking

You usually can't tell by looking. Even the Lowrys concede that "it can be difficult to know whether someone is just marketing a turquoise as enhanced or whether that certain turquoise is actually treated by the Enhanced process."[3] The seller is the one who knows what was done. A treated stone should be disclosed as treated: the FTC Jewelry Guides (16 CFR §23.24) require it whenever a treatment isn't permanent, needs special care, or significantly affects the stone's value.[11]

Secret Questions

  1. Is it natural, stabilized, enhanced, or stabilized enhanced?
  2. If enhanced: was it dyed, hardened, or both?
  3. Will you write the treatment on my receipt?

For stabilized turquoise on its own, see our companion post, What Is Stabilized Turquoise?.

Resources

Source: Fritsch, Emmanuel. McClure, Shane. Ostrooumov, Mikhail. Andres, Yves. Koivula, John. Kammerling, Robert. The identification of Zachery treated Turquoise 1999. Website pdf : https://web.archive.org/web/20230923150041/https://image1.fmgstatic.com/pdf/The-Identification-of-Zachery-Treated-Turquoise.pdf

From the Library: Pogue, The Turquois (1915)

1915 primary source. Anything described as current here describes 1915, not today.

Enhancement is not new. Pogue (1915, p. 72) translated a treatise of about 1300 describing pale turquoise that jewelers smeared with butter to darken it; the darker color was only temporary, and the trade had a name for such stones.

Writing in 1915, Pogue described the trade's view of color-treated stones at the time:

“From time to time turquoises that have had their color deepened or otherwise improved by artificial means come into the trade. As such stones are apt to revert to their original shade upon continued wear, those treated in this manner are not sold except in attempts to defraud.”
— Pogue (1915), p. 133

Pogue (1915) traced the practice back centuries:

“That the turquois may be temporarily improved in color has long been known. Muhammed Ibn Mansur in the thirteenth century mentioned that its color was strengthened by mutton fat or by smearing with butter.”
— Pogue (1915), p. 133

Citing Blake, Pogue (1915, p. 133) reported that the Pueblo Indians of the Southwest heightened the color of their turquoises by soaking them in tallow or grease.

According to Pogue (1915, p. 133), sellers near Nishapur in Persia often carried stones in their mouths before offering them for sale, and dealers in Meshed were said to keep turquoises in moist earthenware pots, because moisture temporarily improved the color of inferior stones.

On dye, Pogue (1915) wrote:

“Off-color stones are sometimes stained with Prussian blue.”
— Pogue (1915), p. 133

From the Library: Branson, Turquoise: The Gem of the Centuries (1975)

1975 primary source. Anything described as current here describes 1975, not today.

Branson (1975) described the stabilized turquoise on his plate:

“No color or dye has been added.”
— Branson (1975), p. 8

Branson (1975) explained why top-grade stone was not stabilized: the plastic

“will not penetrate compact dense material”
— Branson (1975), p. 8

According to Branson (1975, p. 8), treated chunks that were cut open showed only partial penetration: the original pale color in the center and the plasticized color outside.

Branson (1975) photographed soft pieces dipped halfway in resin:

“The tops are the original color, almost white; the lower portion shows the color change the resin causes.”
— Branson (1975), p. 8

From the Library: Lowry, Turquoise: The World Story of a Fascinating Gemstone (2010)

2010 primary source. Anything described as current here describes 2010, not today.

According to Lowry (2010, p. 196), some of the earliest recorded treatments came from Chinese cultures, who rubbed yak fat into turquoise, and Native Americans were known for soaking lower-grade turquoise in bear grease to deepen its colour. [3]

According to Lowry (2010, p. 197), so-called "kitchen treats" can mean soaking low- or medium-grade turquoise in Crisco, mineral oil or vegetable oil, or heating it in paraffin wax, then tumbling it to a polish. Lowry adds that these treatments generally reach only the surface, not the core of the stone. [3]

Lowry (2010) traced American stabilization to Globe, Arizona:

“In the United States during the 1950s and 1960s, on the sunporch of an unknown old man's home, which was located on a hillside above Globe, Arizona, Leonard Hardy and several others were introduced to "soak treating" turquoise”
— Lowry (2010), p. 197 [3]

According to Lowry (2010, p. 198), Hardy, Charlie Voight and others, advised by plastic manufacturers, first put chalk turquoise in a stainless-steel pan with electrodes at each end, added petrochemicals and blue dye, and ran electricity through the mix. They then covered the pan with tinfoil and let the sun cure it for four to six weeks. Lowry records that this "old treat" was later replaced by polyester impregnation without dyes, and that the Colbaugh family was among those who continued and refined Hardy's epoxy-bonding system. [3]

Lowry (2010) named the processes:

“Three methods are named to specifically describe stabilizing processes: simple soaking, vacuum impregnation, and high-pressure impregnation.”
— Lowry (2010), p. 199 [3]

According to Lowry (2010, p. 202), poor stabilization shows. If the resin does not fully penetrate, the centre stays whitish, and stone that was not dried first can crack, form open pockets, or come out with uneven colour or white spots. [3]

According to Lowry (2010, p. 203), James E. Zachery, who came from a turquoise lapidary family, began experimenting in the 1950s. He developed a patented process for medium-grade turquoise, not chalk, that can treat either cut cabochons or rough. [3]

From the Library: Turnbaugh, Indian Jewelry of the American Southwest (2007)

2007 primary source. Anything described as current here describes 2007, not today.

According to Turnbaugh (2007, p. 33), turquoise could be dyed, or stabilized with plasticizing epoxy, resin, oils or waxes, especially when it was a low-grade or soft stone in its natural state. [4]

From the Library: Ryan & Chambless, Turquoise in America Part Two: 1910–1990 (2020)

2020 primary source. Anything described as current here describes 2020, not today.

According to Ryan & Chambless (2020, p. 19), for most turquoise, color or hardness or both are modified to prepare it for use in commercial jewelry manufacture; their book closes with a chapter describing the various treatments. [5]

Marty Colbaugh recalled, in an interview published by Ryan & Chambless (2020, p. 165), that his grandfather got the idea for stabilizing in Globe, Arizona, in 1948, when a friend was setting scorpions and snake heads in epoxy paperweights and he tried the same with a piece of turquoise chalk, and the colour came out. [5]

Marty Colbaugh recalled, in an interview published by Ryan & Chambless (2020, p. 166), that cutters from Idar-Oberstein in Germany came to see the Kingman material and asked for all of it stabilized, because they held that natural stone could eventually turn green and chip when carved, while stabilized stone could be cut paper-thin without changing colour; they paid ten dollars a pound more for it. [5]

Bill King recalled, in an interview published by Ryan & Chambless (2020, p. 148), that he began backing thin turquoise in 1969 so it could be set without breaking, first with plastic wood and then with an auto-body filler, and that within a year backed stones were in high demand in Gallup. [5]

Ron Alexander described, in an interview published by Ryan & Chambless (2020, p. 262), how he understood Jim Zachary's process: Zachary, an electronics engineer in Texas from the Zachary turquoise family, adapted the growing of silicon crystals from circuit-board work to grow crystals inside turquoise's pores rather than filling them with an acrylic, deepening color and hardness; he patented it, and it became known as the enhancing process. [5]

Ron Alexander recalled, in an interview published by Ryan & Chambless (2020, p. 262), that by about 1989 Hardy Turquoise had just acquired the enhancing process from Jim Zachary and was applying it to Chinese rough. [5]

According to Ryan & Chambless (2020, p. 272), over 80% of turquoise must be treated in some way to have the colour and hardness needed for jewelry. [5]

Russell Twiford III, who has treated turquoise since the early 1970s, told Ryan & Chambless (2020):

“Enhancing is just stabilizing with silica, because all turquoise contains some content of silica.”
— Ryan & Chambless (2020), p. 281 [5]

Russell Twiford III told Ryan & Chambless (2020, p. 281) that enhanced turquoise was sold as natural for many years, that it gives a slightly lighter product, and that because it seemed higher grade and was accepted on QVC it sold for more; he added that enhancing usually needs harder material than chalk, whereas stabilizing works at any hardness. [5]

Russell Twiford III recalled, in an interview published by Ryan & Chambless (2020, p. 280), that in the early 1970s stabilized turquoise produced by L. W. Hardy in Kingman was all the craze, because there was not nearly enough natural turquoise to meet demand. [5]

Ron Alexander, a jeweler, dealer and developer of a turquoise treatment, told Ryan & Chambless (2020) what stabilizing does:

“You're essentially just changing the optics.”
— Ryan & Chambless (2020), p. 279 [5]

Ron Alexander told Ryan & Chambless (2020, p. 280) that stabilizing uses acrylic formulations that must be cured carefully or they shrink and show white striations, and that epoxy, which is more viscous, is used when dye is added because pigments separate out of an acrylic treatment. [5]

Russell Twiford III told Ryan & Chambless (2020, p. 281) that colour treatment adds dyes to the stabilizing process to enhance or change the colour, producing fashions such as purple, magenta and lime-green turquoise, and that dark blue epoxy-dyed stone was common when Japanese buyers wanted it. [5]

From the Library: Stacey, Turquoise Blue Book and Indian Jewelry Digest (1975)

1975 primary source. Anything described as current here describes 1975, not today.

Captioning old heishe and nugget strands, the 1975 Turquoise Blue Book noted an old treatment:

“The old necklaces are generally pure turquoise, sometimes pre-treated in hot animal fat to harden the stone and stabilize color.”
— Stacey (1975), p. 17 [6]

Joseph Stacey, writing in 1975, on how little of any find is top grade:

“With turquoise less than 10 percent of any mined quantity will qualify as virgin, pure, super-fine or gem quality. Approximately 15 percent will be judged as top grade to better than average and good.”
— Stacey (1975), p. 85 [6]

Stacey (1975) drew the line here:

“There is nothing new, dishonest or disgraceful about the treating or stabilizing of turquoise.”
— Stacey (1975), p. 85 [6]

And went on, in the 1975 Turquoise Blue Book:

“What is dishonest and disgraceful is the misrepresentation and mislabeling of jewelry using treated and stabilized turquoise at prices comparable to that of gem quality stones.”
— Stacey (1975), p. 85 [6]

From the Library: Jacka, Navajo Jewelry: A Legacy of Silver and Stone (1995)

1995 primary source. Anything described as current here describes 1995, not today.

Joe Tanner of Tanner's Indian Arts, as quoted by Jacka in 1995:

“Today, if you get one hundred pounds of turquoise, only about five pounds is naturally acceptable. Ninety percent of the turquoise today is treated [artificially enhanced].”
— Jacka (1995), p. 82 [7]

On stabilized stone, Gene Waddell told Jacka in 1995:

“And there's nothing wrong with that, if buyers are made aware of the fact that it is not natural gemstone.”
— Jacka (1995), p. 83 [7]

Jacka (1995) on oils, waxes and similar surface treatments:

“This temporarily treated turquoise will eventually fade, usually within a few days to a few months. Unfortunately, it lasts long enough for the unscrupulous seller to pass it off as a good stone to novice buyers.”
— Jacka (1995), p. 84 [7]

From the Library: Welch, Indian Jewelry (1973)

1973 primary source. Anything described as current here describes 1973, not today.

Writing in 1973, Welch gave buyers a simple warning about greased stones:

“Soaking inferior stones in grease gives them a deeper color. When these stones are left in the sun, the grease sweats out of them, and you can feel it.”
— Welch (1973), p. 53 [8]

According to Welch (1973, p. 53), inferior stones were at times shipped to Germany, dyed a deeper colour, and shipped back to the Southwest for the smiths to set. [8]

From the Library: Lund, Indian Jewelry: Fact and Fantasy (1976)

1976 primary source. Anything described as current here describes 1976, not today.

According to Lund (1976, p. 136), by 1976 nearly all stones were sold cut and polished with a black epoxy backing already attached, priced by carat weight with the epoxy included; on stabilized stones the backing added depth and weight to shallow cuts. [9]

Lund (1976) on what the backing hides:

“It also adds density to the appearance, since natural turquoise is never translucent, but stabilized and treated turquoise often is, due to the plastic deposits. Epoxy hides this fact from the buyer.”
— Lund (1976), p. 136 [9]

Lund (1976) tried to clear up the terms:

“To attempt to clear up terminology, you might say that all stabilized turquoise is treated, but not all treated turquoise is necessarily stabilized.”
— Lund (1976), p. 144 [9]

According to Lund (1976, p. 144), stabilizing as practised in 1976 used no dye but impregnated better (never top) grade turquoise with clear acrylics such as diallyl phthalate, while "treated" stones began as soft, chalky material soaked with dye and coated with plastic that often left a whitish core. [9]

Field Notes by Mateo James

In 1915, Pogue wrote that color-improved stones were sold only in attempts to defraud, because the treatments he knew faded back to the original shade with wear. Oscar Branson, writing decades later in Turquoise: Gem of the Centuries, estimated that treated material was "possibly 80 percent of all turquoise mined" and said it should be sold as treated or stabilized. Both views are here so readers can see how the trade's standard moved, from treatment as fraud to treatment as something to label.

The spelling of Zachery's name differs between the sources on this page. The Lowrys and the 1999 identification study spell it Zachery. Ron Alexander, in the interview Ryan & Chambless published, says "Jim Zachary". We follow the Lowrys, and we've left each interview in its own spelling.

Lowry (2010) traces American stabilizing to a hillside above Globe, Arizona, where Leonard Hardy and others learned soak treating from an unknown old man. In Ryan & Chambless (2020), Marty Colbaugh says his grandfather worked out the idea in Globe in 1948 and was the only one doing it at the time. Both stories start in Globe; they differ on whose idea it was, and since one is a family's account, I have left both here.

Lund, writing in 1976, put it this way: all stabilized turquoise is treated, though not all treated turquoise is stabilized. That is our usage too. Treated is the umbrella, and stabilized is one of the labels under it.

Shop the T.Skies turquoise jewelry collection →

Sources

  1. Branson, Oscar T. Turquoise: The Gem of the Centuries. Santa Fe: Treasure Chest Publications, 1975. Cited by printed page. Statements describe conditions as of 1975.
  2. Pogue, Joseph E. The Turquois: A Study of Its History, Mineralogy, Geology, Ethnology, Archaeology, Mythology, Folklore, and Technology. Memoirs of the National Academy of Sciences, Vol. XII, Part II, Third Memoir. Washington, 1915. Public domain. Cited by printed page. Statements describe conditions as of 1915.
  3. Lowry, Joe Dan, and Joe P. Lowry. Turquoise: The World Story of a Fascinating Gemstone. Layton, UT: Gibbs Smith, 2010. Cited by printed page. Statements describe conditions as of 2010.
  4. Turnbaugh, William A., and Sarah Peabody Turnbaugh. Indian Jewelry of the American Southwest. Foreword by Barry M. Goldwater. Atglen, PA: Schiffer Publishing, 2007 (copyright 1996 and 2007; first published 1988). ISBN 0-7643-2577-9. Cited by printed page. Statements describe conditions as of 2007.
  5. Ryan, Mike, II, and Philip Chambless. Turquoise in America, Part Two: 1910–1990. Callais Press, 2020. Cited by printed page. Statements describe conditions as of 2020.
  6. Stacey, Joseph, ed. Turquoise Blue Book and Indian Jewelry Digest. Arizona Highways Collectors Series. Phoenix: Arizona Highways (Arizona Department of Transportation), 1975. Cited by printed page. Statements describe conditions as of 1975.
  7. Jacka, Lois Essary. Navajo Jewelry: A Legacy of Silver and Stone. Photographs by Jerry Jacka. Flagstaff: Northland Publishing, 1995. Cited by printed page. Statements describe conditions as of 1995.
  8. Welch, Frankie. Indian Jewelry: How To Wear, Buy and Treasure America's First Fashion Pieces. McLean, VA: EPM Publications, Inc., 1973. Cited by printed page. Statements describe conditions as of 1973.
  9. Lund, Marsha Mayer. Indian Jewelry: Fact and Fantasy. Boulder, CO: Paladin Press, 1976. Cited by printed page. Statements describe conditions as of 1976.
  10. Indian Arts and Crafts Board, U.S. Department of the Interior (2010), turquoise consumer brochure, p. 2.
  11. Federal Trade Commission, Guides for the Jewelry, Precious Metals, and Pewter Industries, 16 CFR §23.24, "Disclosure of treatments to gemstones"; 16 CFR §23.25(d).

About the author

Mateo James is the founder of T.Skies Jewelry in Albuquerque, New Mexico, and hosts T.Skies live shows, where he has interviewed Native silversmiths, turquoise mine owners and turquoise historians. He is of mixed Spanish, Welsh and Indigenous Native American descent. His guides draw on the reference books in the T.Skies library and on the work of the Native silversmiths T.Skies credits by name.